Charges against Trump could seriously impact the 2024 presidential election. If convicted on any one of them, over 30% of MAGA voters say they would no longer vote for him.
Four criminal cases plus one civil case, 91 criminal indictments, and a potential 561 years in prison:
Let's start with the relatively minor civil case that has already been decided
Civil Case
Carroll v. Trump: Rape Allegation
E. Jean Carroll, now 79, alleged that Trump raped her in a dressing room at Bergdorf Goodman in Manhattan in 1996. The jury rejected the rape claim but found Trump liable for sexual abuse, awarding her about $2 million in damages. Carroll first publicly accused Trump in her 2019 memoir, claiming he raped her in a department store dressing room. Trump called her a "nut job" and said she fabricated a "fraudulent and false story" to sell her book. Carroll then sued him for defamation.
PS: On May 24, 2022, New York's governor signed the Adult Survivors Act, effective November 24, 2022. It allowed victims of sexual assault that occurred when they were over 18 and beyond the statute of limitations to file suit within one year.
In late November 2022, after the law took effect, Carroll sued Trump again for sexual assault. Carroll wrote for Elle magazine for 27 years and also wrote for Saturday Night Live. Her social circle intersected with Trump's at a 1987 party, where a photo shows them together with their then-spouses. Trump has said he doesn't remember the encounter.
1987: Carroll (second from left) with Trump (left, back to camera) and their then-spouses. On May 9, 2023, a federal jury in New York awarded Carroll about $5 million in damages, finding Trump liable for sexual abuse and defamation. Trump denied the allegations.
Key doubts about this case:
-
Carroll could not provide a specific date, only that it occurred in the mid-1990s. She said she told friends at the time, but they also couldn't recall the exact date. There were no eyewitnesses, police reports, medical records, or physical evidence.
-
During the trial, Trump mistakenly identified a photo of Carroll as his ex-wife Marla Maples, contradicting his earlier claim that Carroll was "not my type."
-
Trump is 6'3", Carroll is 5'7". She claimed they had sex standing up in a small dressing room, which seems physically challenging.
-
Carroll filed suit just one month after the Adult Survivors Act took effect. This led 7% of swing voters to say they would vote for Trump, viewing it as a "political witch hunt" against him and an abuse of the legal system.
Criminal Cases:
Adult Film Star Hush Money Case
Trump faces 34 counts of falsifying business records. These stem from a $130,000 payment to Stormy Daniels, an adult film actress, before the 2016 election. Daniels claimed she had an extramarital affair with Trump. While the payment itself was not illegal, using campaign funds without proper disclosure violated federal campaign finance law.
Michael Cohen arranged the payment in October 2016 to prevent Daniels from disclosing the alleged affair from 2006. Daniels signed a non-disclosure agreement. Cohen initially denied the affair but later admitted to the payment. The hush money also raised legal and ethical questions about whether it violated campaign finance laws, as it was not reported as a campaign contribution and may have used campaign funds. (Source: Wikipedia)
January 6, 2021 Capitol Riot
On January 6, 2021, Trump supporters stormed the U.S. Capitol to stop Congress from certifying Joe Biden's election victory. This sparked widespread investigations. A House committee conducted an 18-month probe, holding televised hearings that presented evidence Trump's election fraud claims directly led to the riot. The hearings revealed Trump and his team's actions in promoting fraud claims and inflaming tensions. The committee charged Trump with inciting insurrection and other crimes, based on his tweets, communications with supporters, and campaign rhetoric. The investigation and hearings drew intense public and media scrutiny, sparking debate about U.S. political and electoral systems and how to prevent future attacks.
Notably, Special Counsel Jack Smith provided over 11.5 million pages of evidence in the January 6 case. Trump's lawyers said they would need to review about 100,000 pages per day to meet the Justice Department's schedule for jury selection. They argued: "If we printed all 11.5 million pages and stacked them, the pile would be nearly 5,000 feet high, taller than the Washington Monument." Trump's legal team has requested all trials be delayed until April 2026, citing the overwhelming volume of evidence.
FBI Raid on Mar-a-Lago: Classified Documents Case
The FBI searched Trump's Mar-a-Lago estate in Florida, seizing thousands of documents, about 100 marked classified. The investigation focuses on Trump's handling of these documents and whether he obstructed the FBI's efforts to retrieve them.
Most charges involve willful retention of national defense information under the Espionage Act, each carrying up to 10 years in prison. Other charges include conspiracy, concealment, and hiding documents (up to 20 years each), and false statements (up to 5 years each).
The Justice Department is investigating how the documents were stored and who had access. About 11,000 documents were taken from the White House to Mar-a-Lago, with roughly 100 marked classified, some top secret.
Details of the documents remain scarce. Classified materials typically contain information that officials believe could harm national security if disclosed. The investigation aims to determine if Trump or others broke the law and their motives.
This case has drawn wide attention because it involves a former president and potentially sensitive national security documents. The Justice Department will take appropriate legal action based on findings. We still know little about the documents' content or the investigation's progress.
Source: Department of Justice, CNBC
Many Americans see this as a clear case of "political payback," noting that current President Biden, former VP Pence, and even Obama also had classified documents.
Georgia Election Interference Case
Prosecutors spent eight months investigating attempts to overturn Trump's narrow loss in Georgia in the 2020 election.
A recorded phone call on January 2, 2021, between Trump and Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger was key. Trump said: "I just want to find 11,780 votes" — the number he needed to win the state.
Prosecutors alleged this call constituted election fraud.
Trump later surrendered at the Fulton County Jail in Atlanta. His lawyers negotiated bail terms: $200,000 bond, with conditions not to use social media to target co-defendants, witnesses, or unindicted co-conspirators. He spent about 20 minutes in jail.
Speaking at the airport afterward, Trump called it "a very sad day for America" and said his arrest was an example of "election interference." He said: "This is a travesty of justice. We did nothing wrong. I did nothing wrong, and everyone knows I've never had such support."
The mugshot, taken on August 24, 2023, at the Fulton County Jail, shows Trump with booking number P2313827. He was charged with racketeering and other crimes, along with 18 others. It is the first — and so far only — mugshot of a U.S. president, an instant classic. Within 90 minutes of his release, his 2024 campaign began selling merchandise featuring the photo. His team clearly anticipated the shot and had a plan to capitalize on it — he probably practiced that expression in the mirror.
Bottom line: If Trump loses at trial, what are his chances on appeal to the Supreme Court? Coincidentally, Trump appointed three justices during his term. The Court now has six conservatives out of nine. While justices must follow the law, they may lean in Trump's favor on close questions. Can the case be fast-tracked to beat the November election? No — the Supreme Court has already rejected expedited review. Discovery alone took three years; a quick trial would lack credibility. And if the Court rules for Trump, Democrats can claim bias, potentially hurting his support.
According to a recent Reuters poll, Trump leads Biden by six percentage points.
For more updates, follow:
Boston Round Face's Bilibili Space
